daveroma.com blog

Is watch a movie agreeing to a lie?

Written by David Roma | Mar 15, 2026 6:05:36 PM

Here's a thought I can't let go of. A movie is, at its most basic, a two hour lie. The story didn't happen. The characters don't exist. And the people on screen are professionals at convincingly being someone they are not. We call that acting. But what if we just called it what it is — lying?

And we don't just stumble into it. We pay for it. We sit down, we press play, and we consciously agree to absorb two hours of inauthenticity — for entertainment. We sign up for the lie.

The usual defense is that everyone knows it's fiction, so it doesn't count. But knowing something is a lie doesn't make it not a lie. It just makes you a willing participant in one.

Plato saw this. He wanted actors removed from his ideal society because he believed that making a practice of inhabiting a false self damaged something real in a person. Method actors seem to confirm it — the ones who talk about getting lost, about not finding their way back. When you make a craft of becoming someone you're not, something happens to who you actually are.

So where does that leave us? Maybe the answer is simpler than it sounds: only engage with what's real. A documentary. A conversation. A moment of genuine human expression. And beyond what we watch — practice being authentic within our own lives. Not performing for the room. Not managing how we land. Just being exactly what we are.

Authenticity might not be a personality trait or a buzzword. It might be the only honest way to live.